Japan’s Cleanup After a Nuclear Accident Is Denounced

Ko Sasaki for The New York Times

Bags of contaminated soil outside the Naraha-Minami school near the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant.

NARAHA, Japan — The decontamination crews at a deserted elementary school here are at the forefront of what Japan says is the most ambitious radiological cleanup the world has seen, one that promised to draw on cutting-edge technology from across the globe.

But much of the work at the Naraha-Minami Elementary School, about 12 miles away from the ravaged Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant, tells another story. For eight hours a day, construction workers blast buildings with water, cut grass and shovel dirt and foliage into big black plastic bags — which, with nowhere to go, dot Naraha's landscape like funeral mounds.

More than a year and a half since the nuclear crisis, much of Japan's post-Fukushima cleanup remains primitive, slapdash and bereft of the cleanup methods lauded by government scientists as effective in removing harmful radioactive cesium from the environment.

Local businesses that responded to a government call to research and develop decontamination methods have found themselves largely left out. American and other foreign companies with proven expertise in environmental remediation, invited to Japan in June to show off their technologies, have similarly found little scope to participate.

Recent reports in the local media of cleanup crews dumping contaminated soil and leaves into rivers have focused attention on the sloppiness of the cleanup.

"What's happening on the ground is a disgrace," said Masafumi Shiga, president of Shiga Toso, a refurbishing company based in Iwaki, Fukushima. The company developed a more effective and safer way to remove cesium from concrete without using water, which could repollute the environment. "We've been ready to help for ages, but they say they've got their own way of cleaning up," he said.

Shiga Toso's technology was tested and identified by government scientists as "fit to deploy immediately," but it has been used only at two small locations, including a concrete drain at the Naraha-Minami school.

Instead, both the central and local governments have handed over much of the 1 trillion yen decontamination effort to Japan's largest construction companies. The politically connected companies have little radiological cleanup expertise and critics say they have cut corners to employ primitive — even potentially hazardous — techniques.

The construction companies have the great advantage of available manpower. Here in Naraha, about 1,500 cleanup workers are deployed every day to power-spray buildings, scrape soil off fields, and remove fallen leaves and undergrowth from forests and mountains, according to an official at the Maeda Corporation, which is in charge of the cleanup.

That number, the official said, will soon rise to 2,000, a large deployment rarely seen on even large-sale projects like dams and bridges.

The construction companies suggest new technologies may work, but are not necessarily cost-effective.

"In such a big undertaking, cost-effectiveness becomes very important," said Takeshi Nishikawa, an executive based in Fukushima for the Kajima Corporation, Japan's largest construction company. The company is in charge of the cleanup in the city of Tamura, a part of which lies within the 12-mile exclusion zone. "We bring skills and expertise to the project," Mr. Nishikawa said.

Kajima also built the reactor buildings for all six reactors at the Fukushima Daiichi plant, leading some critics to question why control of the cleanup effort has been left to companies with deep ties to the nuclear industry.

Also worrying, industry experts say, are cleanup methods used by the construction companies that create loose contamination that can become airborne or enter the water.

At many sites, contaminated runoff from cleanup projects is not fully recovered and is being released into the environment, multiple people involved in the decontamination work said.

Makiko Inoue contributed reporting from Tokyo.

This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:

Correction: January 10, 2013

An article on Tuesday about flaws in the cleanup of radioactive contamination from the nuclear reactors damaged after Japan's 2011 earthquake and tsunami misstated, in some copies, the given name of the president of Shiga Toso, a company involved in the cleanup. He is Masafumi Shiga, not Akifumi Shiga. The article also misstated the name of the construction company in charge of decontaminating the city of Tamura. It is the Kajima Corporation, not Kashima. The article also referred incorrectly to Fukushima Prefecture. It contains 100 square miles of the more heavily contaminated areas; the prefecture itself is not 100 square miles. And the article misstated the year that the Japan Atomic Energy Agency announced it was soliciting new decontamination technology. It was October 2011, not 2012.

Anda sedang membaca artikel tentang

Japan’s Cleanup After a Nuclear Accident Is Denounced

Dengan url

https://scienceteko.blogspot.com/2013/01/japanas-cleanup-after-nuclear-accident_10.html

Anda boleh menyebar luaskannya atau mengcopy paste-nya

Japan’s Cleanup After a Nuclear Accident Is Denounced

namun jangan lupa untuk meletakkan link

Japan’s Cleanup After a Nuclear Accident Is Denounced

sebagai sumbernya